safeher
Back to work Case Study · 2024
01 — SafeHer

safeher.

Helping women feel safe at every wait — a service designed around the most vulnerable point of a woman's commute in Karachi.

Year
2024
Role
Service design, end-to-end
Duration
4 months · Thesis
Team
Thesis advisor, 3D designer
Tools
Figma · Procreate · Spline · Blender
SafeHer SafeStop installed on a Karachi street, women seated inside, cars and bus arriving

Commuting shouldn't be a daily battle. Yet, for women in Karachi, it feels like one.

[ User Persona ]

I usually plan and head to the bus station at least an hour and a half early — just to find a bus and reach in time for class.

Nisma Khan University student — 23

The wait times are too long, and it's tough standing at bus stops surrounded by so many men. It can be uncomfortable.

Zinneerah Rafiq Software engineer — 29

"Less public gaze from men and strangers at bus stops would make me feel more comfortable."

"There's always this nagging fear of having my phone snatched or, worst-case scenario, getting shot in a snatching incident where things could escalate."

"I really don't like the public buses here. They're usually overcrowded, hygiene is a big issue, and there aren't enough of them."

"It's really about availability and keeping the costs down."

"I've felt uncomfortable using ride-hailing apps at night. It feels a bit risky sometimes."

"Dealing with all sorts of people on public transport can be challenging. There have been a few uncomfortable moments."

"I've felt uncomfortable and even harassed at times. It happens quite often on buses, sadly."

There was a lot more to the story.

So I had to map the whole thing — end to end — to see the pattern, not just the noise.

Commute isn't just an inconvenience. It's a layered, systemic problem for women.

Through interviews, field observations, and journey-mapping across multiple commute scenarios, one pattern repeated: a single feature wouldn't solve a systemic issue — a service ecosystem was needed. The most vulnerable point in the journey is the waiting phase.

Commute journey map across home, street, waiting station, vehicle and destination, identifying the waiting station as the most vulnerable phase
Journey map Mapped across the full commute — Decide to commute, Get ready, Step out, Walk to station, Wait, Board, Ride, Pay, Walk home. The waiting station — physically exposed and socially uncomfortable — is where every fear concentrates.
01

Long, unsafe waiting times

Buses don't run on schedules. Women plan an extra 60–90 minutes just to arrive on time.

02

Male-dominated public spaces

Stops are physically open and socially uncomfortable — often with no other women in sight.

03

Poorly lit, abandoned bus stops

Most stops lack lighting or signage. They look like risk, not infrastructure.

[ The cost ]
According to PIDE and IIPS reports
40%

Of women avoid travel after sunset

Not because of the commute itself — but because of the waiting around it.

Longer perceived wait time after dark. Fear distorts time, not the bus schedule.
How might we

create a safer, more convenient waiting experience for women commuters in Karachi?

I wanted to fix everything — because it felt that personal.

I explored how design could transform the waiting experience from a vulnerable pause into a secure, visible, and supportive moment.

What women needed
Lighting Shelter Route info Verified drivers Ride options Visibility Predictability Control Dignity
01 — Place

Comfortable stations

Better seating, lighting, and shelter at every stop.

02 — Layer

AR integration & gamification

Live route overlays and reward systems to make the wait feel less idle.

03 — Service

Smart kiosks & payments

Self-service hubs for tickets, top-ups, and route info.

04 — System

Transport super-app

One platform to plan, pay, and track every transit option in the city.

Why this mattered

"For me, this wasn't just a design thesis — it was years of living through the problem."

But the problem wasn't about features. It was about foundations.

After 150 women interacted with my early concepts, one thing was painfully clear: I was designing for a system that barely existed. Their feedback forced me to throw out the features and rebuild from the ground up.

Insight 01

"Women often stood outside the station because there were too many men inside."

Insight 02

"Many people waited under pedestrian bridges or next to poles — using whatever shade or cover they could find."

Insight 03

"Most stations had no proper benches, no shelter, and no clear sign of where or when the bus would come."

Insight 04

"A lot of benches were broken or missing completely."

SafeHer: a multi-layered service that facilitates the wait.

Two interconnected layers — one physical, one digital — designed so neither carries the entire burden of safety alone.

Physical

SafeStops

Secure, gated waiting shelters with lighting, ventilation, transparent walls, CCTV and emergency features — so women aren't exposed, alone, in the dark.

Digital

SafeHer App + Web

Real-time bus tracking, route planning, helpline access, and personalised onboarding — so the wait is informed, not anxious.

SafeHer service blueprint, showing front-stage, back-stage and support processes across awareness, onboarding, decision to commute, arrival, finding a ride, and waiting
Service blueprint Front-stage, back-stage, and support processes mapped across the entire SafeHer journey — from awareness to onboarding to waiting at a SafeStop. The blueprint kept the digital and physical layers in sync, so a single missed handoff couldn't break the trust.

Six outcomes — the hypothesis SafeHer set out to prove.

01

Safe, convenient stops

02

Reduced waiting stress

03

Women-powered community

04

Personalised experience

05

Digital empowerment

06

Accessible public transport

Every element of the SafeStop emerged from real fears, behaviours, and lived experiences.

Three diagrams documented every decision — what was added, why it earned its place, and what was redesigned after testing.

SafeStop anatomy — front: after-hours shutters, transparent glass panels, accessible seating, well-lit interior, secure gated access
SafeStop anatomy — top: round signal lights placed high for visibility, color-coded route map, real-time bus updates
SafeStop anatomy — interior: CCTV, helpline, emergency alarm, ride-signal button, wheelchair accessibility
Anatomy Visibility (transparent walls, round overhead lights), security (CCTV, gated access, emergency alarm), accessibility (ramp, wheelchair seating), and information (real-time bus updates, color-coded routes) — held together as one cohesive object on the street.
What user testing changed

Real users in real conditions, not pristine renders.

  • Drivers didn't recognise the original light strips → redesigned to round overhead lights.
  • Bikes and rickshaws blocked the view of the entrance → entrance was repositioned.
  • Women asked for more seating → expanded bench depth, added a foldable extension.
  • Women felt safer when they could be seen → walls became fully transparent.
SafeHer SafeStop in daylight on a Karachi street, women waiting and chatting outside
SafeHer SafeStop with overhead pink ride-signal lights, jagahonline.com transit hub in background

The app made the stop findable, accessible, and personal.

Onboarding is identity-verified (CNIC) so every member is accountable. The home centres the SafeHer membership card. The map surfaces nearby SafeStops with walk times. Routes show live bus arrivals. Reviews keep the community honest.

01 App flow

Smooth, secure onboarding

CNIC-verified sign-up keeps every member accountable to the community. Identity is the first promise of safety.

SafeHer onboarding — set up your account with name, password, and CNIC
SafeHer onboarding — CNIC scan flow with verification
02 App flow

A home that knows her

The membership card sits front and centre. Frequently visited stops surface below, so the right SafeStop is one tap away — and her profile keeps her commute history, saved routes, and emergency contacts close.

SafeHer home — Zinneerah's membership card and frequently visited SafeStops
SafeHer profile — Zinneerah's account with commute history, saved routes, and emergency contacts
03 App flow

Plan the safest route

Discovery map of nearby SafeStops with walk times, plus a step-by-step route view that makes a long, anxious wait feel intentional.

SafeHer map — nearby SafeStops with walk times around the user's location
SafeHer route — PBS Route 10 timeline from Model Colony to Karsaz
04 App flow

Stay updated in real time

Live bus arrivals at every SafeStop and honest community reviews — so the wait is never a guess, and the trust is never blind.

SafeHer Awami Markaz — live bus arrivals with route IDs and arrival times
SafeHer reviews — community ratings, 4.6 stars across 233 reviews
05 App flow

Safety and accessibility

A direct line to SafeHer Support — one tap, no menus — paired with a physical SafeHer card she can carry through the city. The helpline isn't a feature; it's the floor.

SafeHer Get Physical Card flow — order a SafeHer membership card delivered to her address
SafeHer helpline — direct call to SafeHer Support, with mute, video, and end-call controls
06 App flow

Cards she can craft

Pick a background, pick a phrase. The membership card becomes a small act of expression — and a quiet way to claim space in a city that rarely makes any.

SafeHer Customize Card screen — choose a background and slogan to personalise the membership card
SafeHer card variations — feels like freedom, powherful, make her story, braveher stronger safer, empowhered women, i am safe-her

Built to feel made for her, not made for everyone.

SafeHer wordmark over a woman seated on a bus with her phone — the brand in its natural context
SafeHer app — Awami Markaz arrivals screen, PBS Route 1 in 3 minutes
SafeHer SafeStop in daylight, women seated inside, building façade behind
SafeHer SafeStop daytime — women waiting outside, Karachi street context
SafeHer visual system — Raleway and Outfit typography, palette including SafeHer pink #FA3A8E and teal accent, with iconography
SafeHer physical membership card — Zinneerah Rafiq, SH-2024-0198, helpline on reverse
SafeHer website on a laptop — Feel safe, everywhere you wait
Website The website acts as the trust layer — the answer to "what is SafeHer, and why should I use it?" — before the user ever opens the app or steps inside a stop.

From a thesis prototype to public conversation.

SafeStops were installed and tested at the IVS Degree Show, allowing women to interact with the system in person — and the response moved past curiosity, into demand.

Signals
99%

of 307 women said yes — sign me up.

42%

of those (130 women) said they'd pay a membership fee.

300+

organic sign-ups in the first week alone.

Public showcase
Nabia presenting SafeHer at the IVS Degree Show, with three visitors taking notes in front of the SafeHer panels

IVS Degree Show, December 2024

SafeStops were installed at the IVS Degree Show — visitors, parents, and policy figures interacted with the stops, signed onto the wait list, and offered feedback in real time. The thesis became a conversation about Karachi's transport infrastructure, hosted by women.

01

Policy attention

Recognised by Sharjeel Memon, Senior Minister of Transport & Mass Transit, Sindh — as a scalable public safety concept for women in Karachi.

02

Public demand

307 sign-ups for the wait list and 130 women indicating willingness to pay — demand that travelled past awareness into commitment.

03

Market signal

Featured in Dawn Newspaper as a women-focused urban safety innovation emerging from Karachi's design community.

Featured in
Dawn Newspaper · 15 Dec 2024

"Communication Design graduate Nabia Tariq presents her thesis, SafeHer — addressing the challenges women face when commuting in Karachi."

Read the article

A single feature can't fix a systemic issue. A service ecosystem can.

SafeHer began as a question about safety and ended as a question about infrastructure — a reminder that the most powerful design decisions often happen long before the screen. The work that mattered most wasn't the interface; it was the system the interface sat inside.

More case studies